As Darkness Falls by Bronwyn Parry
The first I heard of As Darkness Falls by Australian author Bronwyn Parry was a small blurb in the Dymocks Booklovers catalogue. I was intrigued because it sounded like a romance (just because the catalogue says it’s romance doesn’t necessarily mean it’ll be genre Romance), it’s set in Australia, and it looked meaty. When I finally got my hands on the book, the cover promises: “If you enjoy reading Nora Roberts you will love…” That is a big call, I thought, especially since it’s the author’s first novel. But after reading As Darkness Falls, I think it really is a book that Nora Roberts fans might like. It’s a shame, then, that so few Australian romance bookstores have it in their catalogues.
As Darkness Falls centres on Detective Isabelle O’Connell, who has isolated herself from society to recover from some serious personal trauma resulting from an investigation into a child killer. Not only had she been unable to find the killer in time, she had been unable to protect a local suspect from falling victim to an angry mob. But when she receives a visit from Detective Chief Inspector Alec Goddard informing her that another girl has gone missing in her hometown of Dungirri, Isabelle is compelled to go back home and help solve the case.
Alec feels guilty about using Isabelle in the investigation, but he’s determined to find the missing girl. Unexpectedly, Alec finds himself unexpectedly drawn to Isabelle despite the fact that he has his own reasons for not wanting to let anyone into his life. For Alec, the case becomes increasingly personal as Isabelle herself becomes part of the killer’s game. Isabelle’s fragile emotional state is further challenged as evidence mounts that the person they’re looking for is a local member of the community–a killer who gets more daring by the day, and whose every move seems calculated to test the very terrors that Alec and Isabelle are struggling to overcome.
Romance with an Aussie sensibility
The romance between Isabelle and Alec develops slowly and believably. Although the crime investigation takes centre stage in the earlier part of the book, we get a glimpse of the growing attraction between the main characters. This is wonderfully understated most of the time, which I think echoes a practical sort of Australian sensibility that’s in keeping with the setting. It was refreshing to read about these characters who felt real to me, and whose manner of expressing affection and desire bear some resemblance to how I think most people fall in love.
Alec is portrayed as a man who won’t take crap from people, but who is capable of great compassion and empathy. Parry explores his character by his actions and reactions as a boss, an investigator, a friend and a lover. He never descends into a stereotype, and even when he feels jealousy against men from Isabelle’s past, he doesn’t resort to playing boorish games. The one thing that didn’t quite work for me was Alec’s main internal conflict about being in a relationship with Isabelle. I felt that this wasn’t well integrated into the story and came across as something tacked on to prevent the romantic plot resolving earlier than the suspense does. And yet it could have been a real obstacle to the romantic plot, so I wish Parry had woven it into Alec’s story better.
Isabelle is a complex mix of toughness and vulnerability. Again, Parry imbues the character with an Aussie sort of disposition in which the practical concerns of everyday life, of the tasks at hand, take precedence over whatever internal struggles she’s going through. This makes Isabelle’s emotional turmoil that much more powerful when Parry lets us into the character’s head. At the same time, it removes any doubt that Isabelle is capable of being part of the investigation even when she’s at her most vulnerable.
What I love most about the relationship between Alec and Isabelle is that it’s underscored by mutual respect and a gentleness that contrasts with the violence they deal with as part of their jobs. I love that Alec gives Isabelle space to be herself, providing support while Isabelle tries to repair her emotional wounds, without asserting himself as any kind of saviour. At the same time, Isabelle rebuilds relationships outside of Alec, so I never feel as though he’s just a crutch for her.
The suspense plot
I admit that I was never sure of who the killer was until Isabelle and Alec work it out. Parry couples Isabelle’s past and the kind of intrigues you’d expect from a small town to keep readers second-guessing their own suspicions. While I admired the way Parry conceals the true killer, I was disappointed by how the main characters come to realise who it is. To me, it seemed too sudden, too capricious. Likewise, the way Alec discards some of the suspects by pure intuition didn’t come across as realistic to me. This was my biggest gripe about the story, because even though I can believe that investigators rely heavily on instinct, I find it dodgy that someone in Alec’s position would discard possible suspects without even a cursory background and alibi check. (And if this is how investigations are conducted in real life, then I don’t feel the author explains this well enough to me as a reader.)
The Australian backdrop
One of the main problems I’ve had with outback romances has been other authors’ inability to portray the backdrop without going over the top. Parry manages it very well, weaving the landscape and the feel of country Australia into the story, that at times I felt I could visualise it, even though I’ve never actually been to the outback (just seen it on TV–what? I hate to sweat!), but never so much that I had to skip parts of the narrative. As Darkness Falls has a very strong sense of place, and Parry paints a picture of the outback in vivid detail without being indulgent. Parry uses Aussie terms and expressions with the understanding that, while the reader might need some things explained, the characters certainly don’t. Aussie culture and knowledge are woven into the story without affecting the pace, and often in a way that gives insight into the characters themselves:
‘Get it down to ballistics in Sydney,’ Alec replied. ‘Call in a crime scene team to go over the creek area straightaway.’ He stopped as Kris shook her head.
‘Sorry, regional specialists aren’t available — I already asked for them. There was a double murder up near the Queensland border last night and we can’t have them until tomorrow at the earliest.’
He stared at her in disbelief. How could they be expected to conduct an investigation without the resources they should be able to count on — resources he took for granted in Sydney?
‘Welcome to bush policing,’ Isabelle commented dryly.
‘Don’t worry.’ Kris gave him a grin. ‘We’re used to do-it-yourself out here. Adam is as good as any forensic team at finding evidence, even without all the high-tech gear.’
Fraser snorted. ‘Oh, sure, having Koori blood gives him magical powers that are better than years of scientific training.’
‘Murri,’ Isabelle corrected him, her eyes cold. ‘The Aboriginal people in this region call themselves Murris, not Kooris. And learning to read the environment is a survival skill that takes years of observation and practice, irrespective of one’s genetic inheritance.
Yay or nay?
As Darkness Falls is an excellent debut novel, and it makes me so glad to finally read an Aussie romance that never once had me rolling my eyes. You can read the first chapter here. If you’re still not convinced, I’d encourage you to check your local library. If, like me, you’ve basically been reading decades worth of US-centric romances, you may find something refreshing and real and genuinely touching in this novel.
A shorter version of this review was submitted to the ARRC09 Reader Challenge. To enter the contest, this review was modified to fit the word count and contest rules. If you’re signed up to the ARRC Lounge, please vote for your favourite review (no, it doesn’t have to be this one).
Where you can buy this book
AUSTRALIA: Dymocks | Ever After | Fishpond | Galaxy | Intrigue | Rendezvous | Romance Direct | Romantic Reflections | Siren | More (no online catalogue) Psst … where are these stores?
DIGITAL BOOKS: Dymocks | Amazon Kindle
WORLDWIDE: Amazon US | Amazon UK
Latest posts by Kat (see all)
- Amazon and Hachette reach a compromise; meanwhile, The Book Depository is being a bit dodgy - November 14, 2014
- Melbourne Cup readers’ sweep 2014 - November 4, 2014
- Blogger blackout - October 24, 2014
- A response to the support received by Kathleen Hale after she stalked a book blogger - October 23, 2014
- Shenanigans in social media – An author brags about stalking a reader - October 19, 2014