Cover doppelgänger: I knew I’d seen those windblown tresses before

By | 14 August 2012 | 5 Responses

Always A Scoundrel by Suzanne Enoch (Notorious Gentlemen, Book 3)What I Did For A Duke by Julie Anne Long (Pennyroyal Green, Book 5)

I love Julie Anne Long, but it took me ages to finally buy this book because I thought I had already read it. Now I realise that Avon has reused the same cover image. No wonder I was so confused!

For some reason, What I Did For A Duke (2011) appeals to me more than Always A Scoundrel (2009). That said, I’m not a fan of artificially windblown hair in general.

I’m curious to know—which cover do you prefer?

5 comments »

  1. Sharon @ Fictionally Inclined

    I prefer <i>What I Did for a Duke</i>, as well.  While the same image is used in both, that cover is less washed out, and the background is prettier.

  2. Jen

    Attribute it to my taste for bedazzlement again, but I love the bright stars in the clinch’s background. Just makes it all sparkly and magical. And then you’ve got that punny quote from Amanda Quick. Brilliant.

  3. Marg

    Looks like a different woman to me. Different nose.

    Then again, what do I know.

    Of the two I do prefer the Long cover 

  4. Kat (author)

    Sharon — Less washed out—yes, that’s it exactly!

    Jen — I tried not to be mesmerised by the stars, but I was weak. And I didn’t notice the pun until you pointed it out. Cover artist humour?

    Marg — I think there was some minor Photoshopping involved. :D 

    Also, I’m reading What I Did For A Duke now, and it’s SO THRILLING. 

  5. L-J @ Love Stories

    Hah.  Everyone is trying to cut costs these days I guess, but like you said it could be working against them.  I read a ton of books and generally remember covers, so Iikely would have done the same as you and not bought it.  And as far as comparing the two goes, yes, I like the second as well.  To use a historical term, the heroine looks positively whey faced in the first.  :)

Leave a comment

Trackback | Subscribe to comments

Subscribe without commenting